No! I discover that Scalpel Magazine is dead, before it even really started to get interesting. I had high expectations, I like the idea of collecting interesting criticism, and to encourage well written reviews and discussions of literature.
There are other places, of course. I found that the Infinity Plus feature review of the Arthur C. Clarke Award shortlist finally is online! I read this review every year, and always find it interesting. Normally it's written by Adam Roberts, but since he was among the nominated he could not do it this year -- instead Abigail Nussbaum did it. It doesn't matter that it's kind of late this year, I'm very interested anyway.